From: simini@aol.com (Simini)
Date: 26 Sep 1999 21:28:23 EDT
Drey,
I have already stated that I disagreed with Lupton's observance of this custom, in another stack of missives. If you will recall, you and I had a brief discussion about whether or not this practice is in fact traditional.
It is precisely because of your note, and a few other notes and comments heard in the basement, that I felt the issue of what is and isn't a "rule" should be addressed.
Thank you,
~ Simini
Challenge (Lupton)
-
DoS Archive
- Archivist
- Posts: 30701
- Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2004 8:27 am
-
DoS Archive
- Archivist
- Posts: 30701
- Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2004 8:27 am
From: rlupton@aol.com (RLupton)
Date: 26 Sep 1999 21:44:16 EDT
I still believe the challenged should set the date and time, but this has always been within reason.
Using Drey as an example, he said he could make it. He said it'd be difficult, but he could make it, and he did.
If he had been entirely unable, the time would have shifted.
~ Lup
Date: 26 Sep 1999 21:44:16 EDT
I still believe the challenged should set the date and time, but this has always been within reason.
Using Drey as an example, he said he could make it. He said it'd be difficult, but he could make it, and he did.
If he had been entirely unable, the time would have shifted.
~ Lup
-
DoS Archive
- Archivist
- Posts: 30701
- Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2004 8:27 am
From: dreystarke@aol.com (DreyStarke)
Date: 26 Sep 1999 23:13:46 EDT
>If he had been entirely unable, the time would have shifted.
>
Oh? When was this? You didn't inform me even when I wished a different date.
And Simini, I read the other post after this topic. You're correct.
- Drey D'erest Sanchez Starke
Date: 26 Sep 1999 23:13:46 EDT
>If he had been entirely unable, the time would have shifted.
>
Oh? When was this? You didn't inform me even when I wished a different date.
And Simini, I read the other post after this topic. You're correct.
- Drey D'erest Sanchez Starke
-
DoS Archive
- Archivist
- Posts: 30701
- Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2004 8:27 am
From: jonalyn@aol.com (Jonalyn)
Date: 27 Sep 1999 00:39:13 EDT
Cygnut
In th' matter 'o th' Lady Alais, rest assured, th' lady wast nae 'eld in contempt. T'was th' ones wh' were, were ta' utter lackwits wh' made attempt t' call 'er 'onor an' integrity inta question.
Ast ta yuir statement th' theee deem anna claim th' a duelin' official wouldst be unsuitable an' biased an' unfounded insult an worthy 'o an apology, perchance thee hae fergotten th' wee bit 'o murky 'istory.
Tis seemin' Ah recall thine attempt ta put thineself forth ast an official fit ta call a long agon challenge. Mos' assuredly an' rightly so were thee denied t' 'onor, considerin' t'was ye hae shown thineself t' nae be unbiased an' neutral in t' matter. Tis right curious th' thee didst make th' attempt wh' with thine manna attempts ta cause th' downfall 'o an' sully th' reputation 'o one 'o th' principles involved in' th' challenge. Tis nae oft th'
an official dost seek ta hae 'erself chosen ta call a challenge match knowin' full well th' said official hae a personal axe ta grind. Perchance thine grasp 'o logic ist ast flawed ast thine argument th' anna official shouldst be found acceptable.
Jonalyn Starfare
Date: 27 Sep 1999 00:39:13 EDT
Cygnut
In th' matter 'o th' Lady Alais, rest assured, th' lady wast nae 'eld in contempt. T'was th' ones wh' were, were ta' utter lackwits wh' made attempt t' call 'er 'onor an' integrity inta question.
Ast ta yuir statement th' theee deem anna claim th' a duelin' official wouldst be unsuitable an' biased an' unfounded insult an worthy 'o an apology, perchance thee hae fergotten th' wee bit 'o murky 'istory.
Tis seemin' Ah recall thine attempt ta put thineself forth ast an official fit ta call a long agon challenge. Mos' assuredly an' rightly so were thee denied t' 'onor, considerin' t'was ye hae shown thineself t' nae be unbiased an' neutral in t' matter. Tis right curious th' thee didst make th' attempt wh' with thine manna attempts ta cause th' downfall 'o an' sully th' reputation 'o one 'o th' principles involved in' th' challenge. Tis nae oft th'
an official dost seek ta hae 'erself chosen ta call a challenge match knowin' full well th' said official hae a personal axe ta grind. Perchance thine grasp 'o logic ist ast flawed ast thine argument th' anna official shouldst be found acceptable.
Jonalyn Starfare